Field note

Leuchtturm1917 Medium A5 vs Bullet Journal Edition 2: A Procurement Manager's Four-Dimension Comparison

2026-11-13 Laurent Dupont

What I compared, and the four dimensions that actually mattered

I keep two notebooks within arm's reach for the same reason I keep a backup vendor on file: the day the primary stops fitting the job, I don't want to be learning a new system under deadline pressure. For the past six months our procurement team has been running the Leuchtturm1917 Medium A5 hardcover and the Bullet Journal Edition 2 side by side — same desks, same meeting load, same weekly review ritual.

This is not a review of which one is “better.” It's a comparison of which one is better for a specific job, and the four dimensions that broke the tie for us: per-page cost, paper behavior under a fountain pen, structural features for archiving, and delivery certainty. The last one, honestly, is the one that ended up costing us the most attention.

Method note: 38 notebooks over six months, 12 users, every order logged in the same TCO spreadsheet we use for office supplies. The tracker runs the mean, median, and mode of our per-unit spend automatically, so I didn't need a mean median mode calculator to spot the pattern — it was sitting right there in the column next to the invoice dates.

Dimension 1: Per-unit price versus per-page cost

On sticker price alone, the Medium A5 wins and it isn't close. Leuchtturm1917's US store listed the Medium A5 hardcover at roughly $24.50 as of January 2025; the Bullet Journal Edition 2 typically lands between $29.50 and $32 depending on the retailer. Verify both before you quote anything internally (seasonal bundles move the number by a few dollars, and I've been burned quoting a stale price to finance).

Size is not a variable here — both are A5, which is 148 × 210 mm, or about 5.8 × 8.3 inches. Same footprint on the desk, same fit in a bag.

But unit price is the lazy comparison. The Medium A5 carries 251 numbered pages. The Bullet Journal Edition 2 carries 206, and a real chunk of those are pre-printed setup and guide pages rather than blank working space. Divide it out: about $0.10 per page for the A5 versus roughly $0.15 for the BuJo Edition 2. That's close to a 50% premium per usable page, which changes the annual math when you're ordering for a team instead of for yourself.

On our 150-unit annual run, the per-page gap works out to somewhere around $700–$750 a year. Real money. Not catastrophic money.

Here's where it flips, and this surprised me: if the pre-printed layout saves each user 20–30 minutes of setup per book, the labor buried in that premium evaporates fast. At a loaded rate of $45/hour, 25 minutes saved per notebook is about $18.75 — more than the entire price difference. So if your team already runs the bullet journal method, the “expensive” one is usually the cheaper one once you price the time. That's the uncomfortable calculus most price-sheet comparisons skip.

Dimension 2: Paper weight and fountain pen behavior

This is where the two diverge hardest. The Medium A5 uses Leuchtturm1917's standard 80 gsm paper. The Bullet Journal Edition 2 uses 120 gsm. For anyone writing with a fountain pen, that 40 gsm gap is basically the whole ballgame.For context on the units: standard copy paper is typically 20 lb bond, which converts to roughly 75 gsm. So the A5's 80 gsm is about what you'd expect from a decent office sheet, and the BuJo Edition 2's 120 gsm sits closer to brochure stock. Paper weight conversions are approximate and vary by mill — treat them as a sanity check, not a spec.

In practice: a fine nib with a moderately dry ink was fine on the 80 gsm A5 — some show-through, no bleed. When I switched to a medium nib with a wetter ink, the A5 ghosted badly enough that I stopped using the back of the page. The 120 gsm handled the same nib without complaint, though no paper is fully immune to a genuinely wet pen (anyone claiming otherwise is selling something).

I should correct something I believed for years. The “thicker paper is always better paper” thinking comes from an era when coated stock was scarce and gsm was the only number on the spec sheet. Surface sizing and coating matter as much as weight. The A5's 80 gsm handles pencil, ballpoint, and most gel pens beautifully — lighter paper with good sizing regularly outperforms heavy paper that feathers.

If your team writes with fountain pens (or you're learning how to write with a fountain pen and don't want to be fighting your notebook while you do it), the BuJo Edition 2 is the lower-drama choice. Keep the nib angle consistent, don't press, use a moderately dry ink, and let the paper do its job. If your team writes with gel pens and ballpoints, this entire dimension is a non-issue.

Dimension 3: Structure, archiving, and the boring stuff that matters

The Medium A5 is the better archive tool, and that one genuinely surprised me. It ships with a table of contents, numbered pages, two ribbon markers, a gusseted pocket, and label stickers for the spine. That last item sounds trivial until you're the person handing 14 quarterly project logs to an auditor and you need them identifiable from the shelf at a glance.

The Bullet Journal Edition 2 gives you a pre-printed key, an index, dot grid, a future log — and 206 pages total. For a personal journal, that's a great head start. For a shared procurement record where every page needs to survive a handoff, the pre-printed sections are mostly overhead, and the shorter page count means you're reordering sooner.

To be fair, if the notebook is going to an individual knowledge worker rather than into a shared file, the pre-printed scaffolding is genuinely useful and the A5's cleaner page is just… blank. Blank is fine. Blank is not a feature.

Dimension 4: Delivery certainty — the dimension that costs the most

If I had to pick one of these four and throw the other three away, it would be this one.

In March 2024 we paid $210 extra on a $3,600 order to guarantee delivery of 150 notebooks before a client summit. The standard-shipping alternative was “probably” going to arrive in time. Not guaranteed. Probably. That word sat on my desk for two weeks, and here's the calculation I kept running: the notebooks cost about $24 each, the summit cost north of $15,000 to put on, and every attendee was supposed to walk out with one in hand.

The rush fee was 6% of the order value. The downside risk was the first impression of the entire event. That's not a close call. After getting burned twice by “probably on time” promises — once with printed materials that landed a day late, once with a shipment that got re-routed — our procurement policy now requires guaranteed delivery dates on anything tied to a fixed event, and we budget the premium before the quotes come in rather than arguing about it afterward.

Rush fees are usually a bad deal for routine restocking. You don't need a guaranteed date for the pens in the supply cabinet. But for onboarding kits, client gifts, and anything with a date printed on the invitation, the certainty is the product — the notebook is just the thing it arrives in.

What I'd buy, depending on your situation

  • Buy the Medium A5 if you're stocking a shared archive, your team writes with gel pens or ballpoints, and you reorder on a predictable cycle. Lower cost per page, higher page count, and a labeling system built for handoffs.
  • Buy the Bullet Journal Edition 2 if your people write with fountain pens, already use the bullet journal method, or you're buying for individuals rather than a shared file. The 120 gsm paper earns its premium on the first page of wet ink.
  • Either way, pay for the guaranteed delivery date when the order has to land before a fixed event. The premium is small relative to what a missed date costs, and “probably” is the most expensive word in a procurement email.

One last thing, and this is the rookie mistake I made in my first year managing this budget: I compared cover prices, picked the cheaper book, and then spent the savings twice over on reorders — because the pages filled up faster and the paper couldn't take the pens half the team was already using. I only believed the “compare total cost, not unit price” advice after ignoring it and eating that mistake. Cost per page is the number. Everything else is a footnote.

Laurent Dupont

Laurent Dupont

Laurent Dupont is a writing-instruments analyst specializing in ballpoint, gel, rollerball, fountain, and fineliner pens, mechanical and wooden pencils, highlighters, permanent markers, whiteboard markers, inks, and refills. He applies ISO 12757-1, ISO 14145-1, and ISO 11540 while comparing line width, writing length, start performance, ink flow, leakage, drying time, cap airflow, eraseability, tip wear, refill compatibility, and storage orientation. His guides help offices, schools, retailers, promotional buyers, and distributors evaluate writing feel, permanence, surface compatibility, safety, color consistency, refill economics, and assortment design.

Need help applying this idea?