There’s no one-size-fits-all answer. Here’s how to figure out what works for your team.
Over the past 6 years of managing procurement for a 200-person tech company, I’ve come to believe that the ‘best’ office supply choice is highly context-dependent. People assume you just compare unit prices—but identical specs from different vendors can result in wildly different outcomes. Let me walk you through four common scenarios where a total cost of ownership (TCO) mindset saved us money, and where the cheap option actually cost more.
Scenario A: Choosing notebooks for branded corporate gifts
You need custom printed Moleskine notebooks for an upcoming client event. The first question everyone asks: how many pages are in a Moleskine notebook? Standard Moleskine classic notebooks come in three sizes: pocket (192 pages), large (240 pages), and extra large (240 pages). But the real decision isn’t page count—it’s whether to go with stock customization or a fully printed order.
I once compared quotes from three vendors for custom printed Moleskine notebooks. Vendor A offered a lower per-unit price but charged $250 for setup and $120 for a ‘color matching guarantee.’ Vendor B’s per-unit price was 15% higher but included everything: design consultation, proof, and free shipping on orders over 500 units. After calculating TCO, Vendor B was $0.47 cheaper per notebook—and we avoided a $1,200 redo when Vendor A’s colors came out wrong.
My advice: never buy custom notebooks on per-unit price alone. Ask for a breakdown of setup, proofing, and shipping fees. If your event budget is under $3,000, consider a stock Moleskine with a foil stamp instead of full print—it’s often more cost-effective and looks premium.
Scenario B: Setting up a home office desk for remote employees
When we outfitted 50 remote employees with home office desks, I almost approved the cheapest standing desk kit. It was $280 per unit. But after reading reviews about stability issues and the cost of returns, I dug deeper. The ‘cheap’ option had a 14% return rate; each return cost us $45 in shipping plus $70 in restocking. Over 50 desks, that’s a potential $805 in hidden costs—not to mention employee downtime.
We went with a mid-range desk at $420 per unit that had a 2% return rate and a 5-year warranty. Total TCO: $21,420 vs $22,805 for the cheap option. The more expensive desk saved us $1,385 and fewer headaches.
Scenario C: Purchasing calculators for the finance team
You wouldn’t think a square root calculator could have hidden costs, but it can. Our accounting team requested basic scientific calculators. The budget option was $12 each. I ordered 30. Within three months, 8 had broken—buttons stuck, batteries leaked. Replacement cost plus time spent reordering ate up any savings.
I switched to a $24 model from a reputable brand. After tracking 90 units over 2 years, the failure rate dropped from 27% to 3%. The TCO per calculator over 3 years: $14.40 for the cheap one (including replacements) vs $8.65 for the durable one. Paying double upfront saved us 40% over time.
Scenario D: Troubleshooting a printer that won’t go online
IT support tickets often start with ‘how to get a printer back online.’ But from a procurement standpoint, the real question is: why are we buying printers that require daily resets? In 2023, I audited our printer-related costs. We had 12 printers across three offices, averaging 2.7 support calls per month each. At $50 per call (internal labor), that’s $1,620/year just to keep them online.
We replaced the worst-performing models with enterprise-grade printers costing 30% more upfront but with built-in remote monitoring and automatic driver updates. Support calls dropped to 0.4 per month. Net savings after two years: $2,460. The cheapest printer isn’t always the cheapest option.
How to determine which scenario applies to you
Ask yourself these three questions:
- Is the item critical to daily workflow? If yes (like printers or desks), prioritize reliability over price. If no (like calculators), you can still apply TCO but with a higher risk tolerance.
- How many units are you buying? High volume (>50) amplifies the hidden costs of failure. Low volume (<10) might not justify premium models.
- What’s the hidden cost of downtime? A failed notebook order delays an event. A failed printer stops payroll. Quantify the hourly cost of that disruption.
Look, I’m not saying budget options are always bad. I’m saying they’re riskier. If you can stomach the risk and you’ve built a buffer for replacements, go ahead. But if you’re managing a $180,000 procurement budget like I do, those risks compound. One bad decision can wipe out a quarter’s savings.
As of January 2025, Moleskine’s standard notebook page counts are confirmed on their official site. For custom printing, I recommend requesting samples from at least two vendors—and don’t forget to factor in the cost of your own time managing the project. That’s a hidden cost too, and it’s probably the biggest one.
Need help applying this idea?