The Best Test of a Supplier Isn't the Big Contract
The fastest way to find out what a vendor really thinks of you is to place a small, weird order and watch what happens. Not the $20,000 annual contract. The $200 one. The one with a question attached that doesn't fit neatly into a catalog.
I've been the procurement manager at a 60-person education services company for going on seven years. I manage roughly $180,000 a year in classroom supplies, teacher learning resources, measurement tools, and everything else that falls under "we need it by Thursday." I've negotiated with 30-plus vendors and logged every order in a spreadsheet I've built, rebuilt, and cursed at more times than I'd like to admit.
And here's what I wish someone had told me in year one: the big orders are easy to get right. Anyone will answer the phone for a $20,000 PO. The small orders—the ones that look like a rounding error on the monthly report—are where you learn who you're actually dealing with.
Small orders expose the hidden cost of "big customer only" thinking
In my first year, I made the classic rookie mistake. I assumed "standard" meant the same thing to every vendor. It doesn't. I once ordered a batch of math manipulatives assuming the packaging was classroom-ready—because that's what "classroom set" meant to me. Cost us a $600 redo and a very awkward email to a principal.
What I learned from that: the vendors who treated my small, confused questions as worth answering are the same ones I now trust with six-figure orders. One supplier spent 40 minutes on the phone with me about a $150 order of whiteboards because I genuinely didn't understand the difference between a lap board and a dry-erase board for small-group work. They didn't make much on that call. But they've made about $40,000 off us since.
That's not sentimentality. That's math. To be fair, I get why some suppliers set minimums—there are real costs to processing any order. But the ones who figure out how to serve the $150 order without making you feel like a nuisance? Those are the ones who earn the $40,000 ones later.
The "weird" requests are the real interview
Here's the pattern I keep coming back to. Every school—and every education company—has a running list of requests that don't fit a clean category. A teacher asks which digital learning resources actually work for a specific unit. Someone wants to know the best digital learning resources for high school algebra when the district platform crashes. A health science instructor needs a reference for an a1c calculator to explain how a glucose measurement works to a class that's more interested in sports injuries than long division. A math teacher keeps asking for a good cylinder volume calculator because the physical model keeps getting borrowed and never returned.
These aren't big-ticket items. Half the time I'm not even ordering anything—they're the questions that come attached to the order.
I started tracking how vendors responded to those questions. Not scientifically—I'm not running a research study—but I kept a column in my spreadsheet: "Helpful beyond the invoice?" Yes or no. Over about two years, the pattern was hard to miss. The six vendors who scored "yes" on that column ended up with the overwhelming majority of our repeat business. Not because they were cheapest (several weren't even close). Because they made the small, messy, off-catalog stuff feel normal.
The dry-erase marker on the couch problem
I want to tell you about a call we get roughly once a quarter, and no, I'm not exaggerating: "How do I get dry erase marker out of a couch?"
It's usually a teacher who took classroom supplies home, or a parent who borrowed a set for a weekend project. The first time it happened, I had no idea. I called a supplier's support line to ask—not because it was in the catalog, but because they were the only ones who'd ever answered a question like that for us. They walked me through it. Rubbing alcohol first, blot don't rub, test a hidden spot. Ten minutes. Free advice on a problem they didn't create and couldn't invoice.
That call didn't generate revenue. It generated something better: I stopped shopping around for that category of supply. Two years later, when we replaced our entire classroom marker inventory, they got it without a bid. That's what small-order goodwill actually looks like on a spreadsheet—it shows up later, in the quiet column labeled "didn't bother looking elsewhere."
Small orders are also the cheapest pilot you'll ever run
There's a third reason I've become almost stubborn about this, and it's the one that convinced my finance director. In Q2 2024, we tested a new STEM kit supplier with a $250 trial order before committing to a $15,000 department-wide rollout. The trial told us more than any sales call ever could—how they packed the shipment, whether the teacher guide made sense to someone who wasn't the person who wrote it, how fast they answered a Saturday email.
The upside of going with the cheaper alternative was maybe $2,000 in savings. The risk was a classroom full of frustrated teachers mid-semester. I kept asking myself: is $2,000 worth potentially derailing a semester? The expected value said go cheap. The downside felt catastrophic. We ran the pilot instead. Looking back, I should have built the pilot step into every category years earlier—but at the time, the urgent always crowded out the important, and the big POs always got the attention.
But small orders kill margins—doesn't that matter?
I get the counterargument. I've heard it straight from vendors: small orders don't justify the labor. Setup takes the same time whether it's one box or a hundred. Shipping is proportionally worse. Returns are proportionally worse. I'm not going to pretend that's not real.
But the "no small orders" crowd misses something: today's $200 order is tomorrow's $20,000 contract—if the relationship survives long enough to get there. The mistake isn't serving small orders. It's treating them like a favor instead of an investment. We didn't have a formal vendor scorecard until year three, and I regret waiting that long. Once we added one, the column that mattered most wasn't price. It was how they handled the question that came with the little order.
Granted, that requires more upfront work than most procurement teams are set up for. But it pays back in a way that a quote sheet never shows you. If you want the general principle in procurement-speak, it's total cost of ownership—TCO includes the hidden line items most buyers never see until it's too late. If you want it in plain language: cheap upfront is expensive later.
The bottom line
I'm not saying every supplier should lose money on $50 orders. I'm saying the suppliers who find a way to say yes—or who say no while pointing you toward someone who can actually help—are the ones who earn loyalty that never shows up in a bid comparison. Small doesn't mean unimportant. It means potential.
And if you're on the buying side, the fastest way to find your real partners is to watch how they treat the small, strange requests. That's why I shop the way I do. And it's why, when a teacher asks me for the best digital learning resources for high school, or a cylinder volume calculator, or—yes—help with dry erase marker on a couch, I call the vendors who've already proven they'll pick up.
Need help applying this idea?